Systems of Cities: Harnessing urbanization for growth and poverty alleviation
The World Bank Urban and Local Government Strategy
A
summary: Systems of Cities -
Integrating National and Local Policies -
Connecting Institutions and Infrastructure
From the earliest times, cities have been centers of democracy, creativity, and economic
activity. Why? Economics and geography inform us that density and agglomeration are
essential for productivity and growth. Cities also serve as catalysts for collective action,
decision-making, and accountability.
The World Bank is putting forth its new Urban and Local Government Strategy at a critical
time. For the first time in history more than half the world’s people live in cities. Over 90
percent of urban growth is occurring in the developing world, adding an estimated 70 million
new residents to urban areas each year. During the next two decades, the urban population
of the world’s two poorest regions— South Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa—is expected
to double.
It is estimated that today one billion people live in urban slums in developing countries.
Improvement in urban conditions, as demonstrated by many successful programs around
the world, shows that slums can become vibrant and well integrated parts of a city, as in
Senegal, Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam. The demands of poverty alleviation, climate
change and sustainable growth will put today’s developing cities to the test. An estimated
70 percent of greenhouse gas emissions come from cities and more than 70 percent
of energy is consumed in urban areas. This places cities at the forefront of the climate
change agenda where denser, more compact cities will be the essential urban form in
the years ahead.
The new strategy also inaugurates the Decade of the City, a decade that will be remembered
for recognizing cities at the core of growth and human development. Never
before has there been so much interest in cities: city associations, citywide programs, cityuniversity
and private sector partnerships. In developing countries, cities often provide the
first opportunity for elected officials to meet their constituents, governments to collect
taxes, taxpayers to demand efficient services, investors to start new businesses. This
is where collective voices are heard and accountability matters.
Table of contents, acknowledgements, acronyms and abbreviations
Executive Summary
Urbanization is a defining phenomenon of this century, and the developing world is
where this demographic transformation is taking place. In the decade since the preparation of
the last World Bank urban strategy, the world has become, for the first time, more than half
urban. Over 90 percent of urban growth is now occurring in the developing world and nearly two
billion people will become urban residents in the next twenty years. In Africa and South Asia
urban populations are expected to double during this period. Much of this urban growth is
occurring in medium and small-sized cities, with about 53 percent of the world‘s urban
population residing in cities of 500,000 or less. This demographic trend raises important
questions about the process of managing urbanization and delivery mechanisms for urban
development assistance in the decade ahead.
Taking Stock: A review of the Bank's urban development assistance
The World Bank‘s portfolio of development
assistance, like its member countries, has been urbanizing over time. Since its first urban lending
operation was approved in 1972, a sites and services project in Senegal, the Bank has financed
investments and technical assistance in more than 130 countries in the six regions and within
those countries, in more than 7,000 cities and towns. The urban portfolio has included investment
in shelter, infrastructure, slum upgrading, municipal development, local economic development,
natural disaster management, environmental improvements, and social services. Today, the
portfolio includes more than 155 operations in more than 60 countries amounting to US$10.3
billion in lending commitments.
Upsurge in Urban Lending. After a steep decline in lending in FY2000-01, linked to the
overall reduction in overseas development assistance and the Bank‘s shift away from
infrastructure lending, the Urban Portfolio7 has rebounded. Today, total lending surpasses any
previous volume over the past two decades with the sharpest increase in the most recent two years
(FY2008-9).8 Likely contributing factors are (i) increased client demand for urban operations in
response to urbanization pressures and the increasing urbanization of poverty, (ii) impact of the
Bank‘s Infrastructure Action Plan (FY2004-7), and (iii) an increase in urban analytical work.
Urbanization in a national context: A system of cities approach
A paradigm shift in thinking about urbanization. Urbanization in the developing world
was once considered too fast and unmanageable, something to be resisted and controlled. Efforts
by many national, state and local governments over the past several decades have been devoted –
through various policies and interventions -- to curb or contain it. Indeed, this thinking represents
the ―old paradigm.‖ Increasingly, policy makers are recognizing that urbanization is not only
inevitable, but also a powerful force in support of economic growth and poverty reduction. The
emergence of this ―new paradigm‖ is grounded in the notion that density -- and the urbanization
that drives it -- is essential to achieve agglomeration economies and productivity gains. Function,
and not size, is the metric by which a city‘s performance should be measured, raising important
questions about how to manage the process of urbanization and harness its potential for economic
development.
What are the key principles for efficient and inclusive urbanization? The World
Development Report 2009 entitled -Reshaping Economic Geography- identifies higher densities,
shorter distances and lower divisions as the essential building blocks for economic success.
Further, it points out that no country has grown to middle income status without industrializing
and urbanizing...
Thematic Area 1: Focusing on the core elements of the city system
A City System Approach to Urban Development. Understanding urban development
through a city system approach represents a departure from previous strategies. Like all systems,
a city system is fundamentally dependent on the smooth functioning of its constituent elements.
For the purposes of this Urban Strategy we focus on what are the most essential, core elements of
the city system – management, finance and governance – all of which fall within the domain of
local governments. These three core elements need to function well in order for a city to deliver
on its mandate. And when they don‘t the prospects for city residents, particularly the urban poor
are worsened. Good management and information systems, coupled with good leadership are
fairly ineffectual if not equipped with adequate financing. Similarly, a city without a
commitment to good governance and accountability will have difficulty in mobilizing tax revenue
from its citizens or financing from the market. While all thematic areas of this strategy are
important to cities and urban development, the core elements of the city system remain the most
basic and central focus in the decade ahead. In this section, the Strategy examines the three core
elements of the city system: management and service delivery, governance, and finance.
Thematic Area 2: Making pro-poor policies a city priority
Urban poverty is estimated to affect approximately one third of all urban residents, or
one quarter of the total poor in the developing world. The share of the poor as a proportion of
all urban residents is highest in Sub Saharan Africa and South Asia, at an astounding 70 to 75
percent. In regions where urbanization is already significantly advanced, such as Latin America
and the Caribbean and Eastern Europe and Central Asia, the proportion of urban poor relative to
the total poor is greatest. Research suggests that over time poverty is urbanizing, as an increasing
number of the poor now live in cities. This situation has been exacerbated most recently by the
global food and financial crises, which have reversed many of the advances in poverty reduction,
particularly in urban areas. Urban populations are typically hardest hit due to job losses and wage
reductions in urban based industries, their heavy reliance on the cash economy, and the lack of
ability to fall back on agricultural production.
Thematic Area 3: Enabling city economies
With more than half of World GDP coming from cities, the economic future of most
developing countries will be determined by the productivity of these burgeoning urban
populations. As the WDR 2009 points out, urbanization is necessary for growth but is not
sufficient to assure it. The interdependency between macro-economic performance and urban
welfare has been seen in the aftermath of macro-economic crises in Argentina, Brazil, East Asia,
and Russia, where the poor have fallen farther than their middle class counterparts. On a global
basis about 70 percent of economic production takes place in cities. Developing countries are
rapidly increasing the urban shares of their GDP, with most countries already surpassing the 60
percent level. But the results in this regard are highly conditioned on whether a country
proactively plans for and enables urbanization while managing the downside risks. The benefits
of agglomeration have been well-documented in East Asia where cities have been a major part of
rapid economic growth in countries such as China, Japan, Korea, or Malaysia. The case of
China is perhaps most revealing, with 50 percent of GDP generated in coastal urban
agglomerations accounting for only 20 percent of the territory. Many of the Bank‘s client
countries have cities that would like to emulate China‘s experience and local economic
development approaches are in high demand.
Thematic Area 4: Encouraging progressive urban land housing markets
There are four key housing and land issues that consistently pose the greatest challenges
in most urban areas – (i) planning for markets, (ii) public land management, (iii) property rights,
and (iv) housing finance. Dealing with each set of challenges requires putting policies in place to
push formal housing and land systems ―down market,‖ while at the same time creating and
sustaining more ―bottom-up‖ approaches that serve the poorest. Each is addressed in more detail
below.
Thematic Area 5: Promoting a safe and sustainable urban environment
Promoting a safe and sustainable urban environment is a key priority of the Bank’s
Urban Strategy. In this section we review key challenges, consider what innovative cities are
doing today, and outline approaches that the World Bank will support over the coming decade
under its Urban Environment, Climate Change and Disaster Management Business Line.
Operationalizing the urban strategy
The previous sections of the strategy reviewed recent urban developments against five
thematic areas that define the Bank‘s business lines and intervention strategies with respect to
policy advice, analytical work and investment lending. Lessons learned over the past decade
based on a review of urbanization trends, key challenges and performance issues for local
governments, and operational interventions within the Bank‘s urban development portfolio will
help shape the new urban agenda for the decade ahead.
References
ANNEXES:
A. Results Framework and Monitoring & Evaluation Plan
B. Regional Urban Program Strategies
C. Knowledge Products
D. Urban Portfolio Charts & Tables
E. Referenced Analytical Figures & Tables
F. Data Tables
G. Urban Thematic & Project Profile Boxes
Tables, Figures and Boxes
Results Framework and Monitoring & Evaluation Plan
Table A-1: Timetable & Indicators for Monitoring Implementation of
the New Strategy in the Bank
Table A-2: Urban Strategy Results Matrix (Global Dimensions)
Table A-3: Urban Strategy Results Matrix (Bank Contribution)
Urban Portfolio Charts & Tables
Figure D-1: World Bank Urban Development Lending and Share of Total IBRD/IDA Lending
Figure D-2: Number of World Bank Urban Development Operations and Share of Total IBRD/IDA Operations
Figure D-3: Urban Development Lending by Region FY00 – FY09 and Regional Share of Total World Bank Lending
Figure D-4: Urban Sector Lending by Main Business Line, FY00 - FY09
Referenced Analytical Figures, Charts & Tables
Figure E-1: Urban Agglomerations by GDP Per Capita
Figure E-2: Phases of Urbanization in Colombian Cities
Figure E-3: Urban and Rural Population Growth
Figure E-4: Urban Population Growth
Figure E-5 Projected Population Growth between 2000 and 2015 by Size
Figure E-6: Urban Population Access to Improved Sanitation
Figure E-7: Headcount Index (%) in Urban Areas Using a $2/Day. Poverty Line Compared to % of Population that is Urban
Figure E-8: Urban Slum Population
Figure E-9: Carbon Dioxide Emissions Compared with urban Population from 1967 – 2005
Figure E-10: Countries with Most Urban Populations Living in Low Elevation Coastal Zone
Figure E-11: Price of Land Compared to Floor Area Ratio in a City in China
Figure E-12: Land and Construction Cost Compared to Floor Area Ratio in a City in China
Figure E-13: Household Income Distribution and Housing Affordability in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Figure E-14: Sub-National Expenditures (% of Total)
Figure E-15: Map of Population Density in Accra, Ghana
Figure E-16: Map of Population Density in Guangzhou, China
Figure E-17: City Densities and GHG Emissions per capita
Table E-1: Feedback from Client National and Local Governments and Development Partners
Table E-2: Local Government Responsibility for Service Delivery
Table E-3: Capital Flows to Emerging Market Countries
Table E-4: Innovative City Initiatives that Promote Sustainable Urban Environment
Table E-5: Overview of Bank Urban Strategy Response to Key Challenges
Table E-6: Urban & Local Government Strategy in a Cross-Sector Framework
|